Author Archives: SOS

State Election Forum – PLANNING BRUNSWICK’S FUTURE

Should there be firm height limits?
Does the community have enough say?
Will traffic choke our suburb?
THURSDAY 11 NOVEMBER 6.30-8.OOpm

 
State Election Forum 2010
CLARRIE WOHLERS CENTRE, FLEMING PARK, 
51 ALBERT STREET, EAST BRUNSWICK
 
Candidates speaking:
• Jane Garrett (Labor)  
• Cyndi Dawes (Greens) 
• Liberal Party representative
• Trent Hawkins (Socialist Alliance) 
• Phil Cleary (Independent — if standing)
• Bill Cawte (Independent)
 
Chair: Shane Maloney Brunwick writer
 
All welcome!  Includes Q&A from chair, plus audience questions.
Organised by local residents’ network.
More info: albertstreet2020@gmail.com  0421 840 100
 
Authorised by Nancy Atkin, 135 Albert Street Brunswick

 

PUBLIC PLANNING FORUM – Richmond Town Hall 4pm, Sunday 7th Nov

POPULATION – MELBOURNE’S PLANNING PUZZLE
Melbourne’s population is over 4 million 
They are planning for 8 million 
Is that too many?
How many is too many?
 
IS SUSTAINABILITY IMPORTANT  ?
Infrastructure, who pays for it ??

 

PUBLIC FORUM
Richmond Town Hall
333 Bridge Rd, RICHMOND
4pm, Sunday 7th November 2010

Speakers:
Andrew MacLeod, CEO Committee for Melbourne
Kelvin Thomson MP, Federal Member for Wills
 
Panel:
Melina Sehr – Stonnington City Councillor
Rupert Mann – Melbourne Heritage Action Group
David O’Brien – Planning Barrister
Mary Drost – Convenor Planning Backlash
 
Moderator – David Trenerry
 
Sponsor: PLANNING BACKLASH INC.

Notice of SOS 2010 AGM – 3pm 14th Nov 2010

  Save Our Suburbs Inc (Vic) will hold its 2010 AGM on Sunday 14th November 2010 at 3pm at The Elsternwick Club, 19 Sandham St Elsternwick (Melways 67 G3).

GUEST SPEAKER

Julianne Bell, Secretary of Protectors of Public Lands Vic), will outline some of the positive actions that PPL and other groups have been taking recently to oppose planning and transport projects that increasingly threaten the residential amenity of Melbourne.

Protectors of Public Lands is a coalition of community, environmental and heritage organisations formed to protect and preserve significant public lands in public ownership for present and future generations.

Refreshments will be served after the meeting

At this AGM, SOS will:

  • Confirm the minutes of the last preceding annual general meeting; 
  • Receive reports from the Committee on the Association’s transactions during the last financial year –
    • Consider the statement submitted by the Association under section 30(3) of the Act. 
  • Elect officers of the Association and the ordinary members of the Committee
    •  (NB: At this AGM, the President, Treasurer and three ordinary committee members will be elected. SOS members financial until 30 June 2010 or later are eligible to vote)

 

Proxies:               If you are a financial member unable to attend the AGM and wish another financial member to act on your behalf at the meeting, please complete the Proxy form on the back of this notice (or download one from the web site) and return it to the Secretary at the address below (or use the included envelope) by 3pm, Thursday Nov 11th, 2010.
 
Nominations for the committee must:
 
  1. be made in writing by a current financial member, signed by two other financial members of the Association and accompanied by the written consent of the candidate (which may be endorsed on the form of nomination); and
  2. be delivered to the Secretary of the Association not less than seven days before the date fixed for the holding of the annual general meeting (ie before the 7th of November, 2010). 
A nomination form is on the SOS web site (www.sos.asn.au), but any format is acceptable as long as it contains the required information. Any candidate statements will be posted unedited on the SOS web site (email well beforehand to sos@sos.asn.au). If you would like a mailed statement or nomination form, contact us on 9513 9674 and we’ll post you a copy.
 
Candidates should send nominations directly to:   
               The Secretary
                Save our Suburbs
                 PO Box 739
                 Richmond 3121

Ian Wood,

President, Save Our Suburbs

Forum – Melbourne’s Urban Growth Boundary

7pm Thursday 9 Sept, RMIT Bldg 50, Orr St Carlton                                            entry – gold coin donation                                     

The State Government recently announced that Melbourne’s Urban Growth Boundary would be expanded by around four times the size of Phillip Island to accommodate 134,00 new houses (just over 3 dwellings per hectare – very low compared to the 10 dwellings/ha average for suburbs south-east of the CBD).

The decision was supported by the Coalition and applauded by housing and property industry groups which claimed the expansion would make housing more affordable.

But it also caused disbelief and dismay among other parts of the built environment profession – planning groups and the community in general.

Melbourne’s steady outward sprawl has been long criticised for pushing people further from jobs and services, forcing car dependence and subsuming much-needed agricultural land. Now it looks like the sprawl may be here to stay. But:

– is this really the answer to housing affordability?

– how does this expansion impact on social and ecological sustainability?

– what does this mean for Melbourne in general?

 

Join in this public forum as we explore these issues with a number of leading experts:

Paul Mees, lecturer at RMIT GLobal Studies, Science & Social Planning

Stuart Worn, CEO, Planning Institute of Australia

Ian Wood, President, Save our Suburbs

Tony Di Domenico, executive director, Urban Development Institute of Australia

Carolyn Whitzman, associate professor in Urban Planning, University of Melbourne

Kate Shaw, ARC research fellow, University of Melbourne

Dianne Moy, project coordinator, Victorian Eco Innovation Lab

Maree McPherson, CEO, Victorian Local Governance Association

chaired by Ian Woodcock, research fellow in Urban Design, University of Melbourne

                                                                                                                                                                     words@bld50 – monthly talks in 2010                                                                                                           www.architectsforpeace.org

NEW PHOTO EXHIBITION – HARBINGERS OF CHANGE: CITIZENS AND SUSTAINABILITY

Coburg Town Hall,  Aug 12 – Sept 29

This
 photographic 
exhibition 
portrays 
some
 of 
the 
diverse 
range
 of 
Victorians 
who, 
faced

with 
evidence 
of 
climate 
change 
and 
environmental 
degradation, 
have 
acted
 to 
live 
more

sustainably. 

The 
images 
(by 
John
 Werrett, 
curated 
by 
Morag 
Loh)
 show 
home
 and

workplace 
initiatives by individuals 
who
 aren’t 
waiting 
for 
government 
leadership 
but

providing 
their 
own
 solutions
 to
 one 
of 
the 
most 
challenging 
issues 
of 
our 
times.

 

WestWyck
 Eco 
Village, 
West 
Brunswick, 
a 
model 
of 
sustainable 
development


Westwyck 
aims 
to 
minimise 
reliance 
on 
mains 
water 
and 
lessen 
discharge 
via 
storm
 water 
and 
sewer.
  A 
CSIRO 
study 
found 
WestWyck 
town
houses 
and 
apartments 
consumed 
64% 
less 
mains 
water 
than
 similar 
housing
 serviced 
by 
Yarra 
Valley 
Water.  
Rain
water 
from 
the 
roof 
is 
heated
 by 
solar 
energy 
to
 provide 
hot 
water.  
Grey
water 
from 
kitchens
 and
 bathrooms 
is 
treated 
to 
Class 
A 
Standard
 and
 used 
to
 flush 
toilets 
and
 water 
gardens.  
Organic 
kitchen
 and 
toilet 
waste 
is 
treated 
in 
a 
large
 worm 
farm.
 The
 resulting 
liquid 
is
 pumped 
through 
evapo‐transpiration 
beds
 and 
filtered 
by
 indigenous 
plants 
such 
as
 local
 grasses 
and
 woolly 
ti‐tree.  
Excess 
water 
goes 
to 
the 
sewers.



WestWyck
 also
 demonstrates 
the
 two 
other
 key
 sustainability 
principles 
of 
efficient 
use
 of 
materials 
and
 energy

SEE
 THE 
"HARBINGERS 
OF 
CHANGE"
 PHOTO
 EXHIBITION 
AT:


Coburg Town Hall,
90 Bell St Coburg

August 12 – September 29, 2010

(for more details see City of Moreland website – www.moreland.vic.gov.au)

Labor backed Windsor Hotel sham – The Age, 28 April

ALP state government MPs and senior staff in the planning department discussed the initial strategy to refuse the Windsor re-development, the Age revealed today.  When the infamous leaked email first became public, the Premier and the Minister swore that the fake public consultation plan was just the concoction of a junior advisor. It’s a tragedy for democracy when neither the government nor the department can be trusted to deal fairly, transparently and accountably with the community.

AGEPOLL:   Should Madden be sacked?  (CLOSED APRIL 30):                                                   YES – 92%;  NO – 8%.   Total votes: 4707.
www.theage.com.au/polls/victoria/should-madden-go/20100427-tpo5.html

See the full Age article here:                                                                                   www.theage.com.au/victoria/labor-backed-windsor-sham-20100427-tq34.html    

 

Project Melbourne – revealing articles on urban planning by The Age

Project Melbourne: towards a sustainable city
PAUL RAMADGE, EDITOR-IN-CHIEF    
March 16, 2010

"These days, everything is faster, busier and more congested. A city of human scale has morphed into a 21st-century city. Apartments are towering over quarter-acre blocks. Melbourne has grown out and up. We are on our way to becoming the nation’s biggest city, yet a shared vision of how we would like to live is still lacking.

Project Melbourne is a special series by The Age aimed at encouraging and broadening public debate about Melbourne’s future — particularly the inner 40 kilometres. We are keen to get your views and feedback."
http://www.theage.com.au/victoria/projectmelbourne

Click here for a Multimedia special on Project Melbourne <http://www.theage.com.au/interactive/2010/times/25/>

 

SOS April newsletter

The April 2010 SOS newsletter is now online!  In this issue –
*  Thumbs down to the Draft Planning Bill and the VCAT Review Report
*  The Romsey pokies case
*  Sydney's Independent Public Transport Inquiry

Download the April newsletter from the link below:
 

 

Melbourne 2030 Implementation Reference Group – critical reports

After M2030 was introduced in August 2002, the State Government also set up a formal statutory committee to advise the government on its implementation.  However, when Justin Madden took over from Rob Hulls as Planning Minister in 2007, one of his first actions was to unilaterally abolish this Implementation Reference Group.

The IRG consisted of representatives from a range of academic, community, industry and development organisations, including SOS.  It was the government's only formal link to the wider community for feedback on rolling out the M2030 policy in practice. 

However, the IRG was critical of the way the government had introduced the policy before most of the necessary council structure plans and upgraded public transport services had been put in place. 

In particular, it was critical of the Metropolitan Transport Plan (launched November 2004) and the way M2030 seemed to be operating in an ad hoc way without the necessary inter-departmental support.

As the failings of the implementation of M2030 became increasingly apparent, all mention of the M2030 IRG and related documentation (reports and minutes) was quietly removed from the DPCD website with Stalinesque sleight of hand in February 2009.  "Melbourne @ 5 Million" (introduced in December 2008) was now the order of the day and earlier policy failures were best forgotten or given a new slant.

The only critical online record left of the implementation of M2030 is Rob Moodie’s 2008 M2030 Audit Report – a little too important and significant to bury.

However, SOS managed to save most of the M2030 IRG documentation as an invaluable record of how badly the M2030 policy was implemented.  The following IRG reports are still available below:

OVERVIEW OF THE I.R.G. (by DPCD)

PRIORITY IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES – February 2004

CHALLENGES TO IMPLEMENTING THE ACTIVITY CENTRE POLICY – July 2004

RESPONSE TO THE METROPOLITAN TRANSPORT PLAN – February 2005

An Activity Centre Thematic Working Group (ACTWG) was also set up as a sub-committee of the M2030 IRG and directed by the Minister to try and find "best practice" cases of development projects under M2030 in activity centres to try and promote the "benefits" of M2030.

EXAMPLES OF M2030 PROJECTS – WEBPAGE 

This webpage of examples is missing.  However, as part of the Working Group, SOS made a submission in June 2006 (see download links below) criticising many of the projects initially nominated. Significantly, none of those we critiqued were included in the final list which was compiled in September 2007, but too late to save M2030 from having to be "re-badged".  This list included:    

Pentridge Village, Coburg 
Bayside Entertainment, Frankston 
Maddern Square Redevelopment, Footscray 
Residential Redevelopment, Newport 
Pelican Park Precinct, Hastings
Apartment Building, Elsternwick
Mixed Use Development, Bentleigh 
Carnegie Library & Community Centre

As well as the IRG background, its 3 reports and the SOS submission, for completeness the minutes of the 8 IRG meetings are also archived below in the list of attachments.

*   For a detailed critique outlining the reasons for the failure of Melbourne 2030, see Paul Mees' account:  "Who Killed M2030?"

 

Ian Wood

SOS President

 

RALLY to SAVE THE WINDSOR

– SAVE OUR CITY 
– SAVE OUR HERITAGE

Rally – Thursday 25 March, 1 pm;  Steps of Parliament Spring Street

Victorians have been enraged and appalled by Planning Minister Madden’s decision
to approve the redevelopment of the Windsor Hotel.
 
The community has not been given its chance to be properly heard – so come along
and let the government know what you think. The Windsor is threatened with a 91m
tower addition in a ‘return to facadism’. Development and heritage can and must live
together however the parliamentary precinct deserves proper protection not
discretionary height controls.

We call on the government to work with City of Melbourne to deliver a proper structure plan for the precinct. Discretionary controls in the hand of the Minister are insufficient.
 
We need to press home the need for changes to planning process on developments
over 25,000m2 – for which the Minister is currently the Responsible Authority. The
City celebrates its 175th birthday this year yet has many significant places that still
lack heritage controls – we call on the City of Melbourne to act now.
 
The National Trust of Australia (Vic), Planning Backlash and Protectors of Public Lands have
joined forces to hold a protest rally.
 
Thursday 25 March, 1 pm;  Steps of Parliament Spring Street
Transport: Train to Parliament Station; tram up Collins St. or Bourke St, W Class on City Circle.
 
Bring Banners and Placards!
The weather will be warm so bring hats, sunscreen and water! 
Ask your friends and relations to attend. It’s time to put on a show of strength.
 
Contact: 
Paul Roser, National Trust email: paul.roser@nattrust.com.au
Julianne Bell, Protectors of Public Lands Victoria  0408022408
Mary Drost, Planning Backlash  0401834899
http://www.MARVELLOUSMELBOURNE.ORG
 
Make your voice heard on what you value about our city’s
heritage architecture before it’s too late!